Black Magic Sanction (Hollows)
by Kim Harrison
Cover Artist: Larry Rostant
Review by Steve Sawicki
Eos Mass Market Paperback ISBN/ITEM#: 9780061138041
Date: 01 January 2011 List Price $7.99 Amazon US / Amazon UK / Show Official Info /
This is the eighth book in Kim Harrison's Hollows series. This time witch Rachel Morgan has to deal with the coven, which has shunned her and wants her imprisoned or at least lobotomized so she's no longer a black magic problem for them. Rachel also has to deal with Trent Kalamack, elf and tycoon industrialist who wants Rachel on a short leash or incapacitated as well. And then there's the demon who has marked her and who is showing her black magic. Add in Pixie Jenks who has his own issues to manage, Ivy who is a vampire and similarly engaged, Pierce a dead witch in another's body who is a black magic user and apparently on his own side, and some men from Rachel's past who are proving much more trouble than they are worth and there's a lot going on that Rachel has to manage.
Rachel's plans seem to continually come to bad endings and her power over her own destiny seems small. If she's not able to pull together many of those who are working against her then there is no way she'll be able to get the coven to change their mind.
I've enjoyed this series up to now. This time though the book feels overly fat, overly fluffy, and in need of a good edit. It's hard to tell whether this is the writer going on unchecked or a change of editor or just market forces which say bigger is better, but as I read I could not help but keep saying to myself this should be shorter. There's a lot going on but much of it is ancillary to the main plot which could have also been tightened and made sharper in focus. The one feeling I kept coming away with was that the author didn't have a solid plot but did have three subplots and decided to weave them all together. This is pure speculation on my part of course but that's certainly what if feels like.
I think that there is enough here for long time fans to still enjoy. The characters that they have come to know are all present, and if the overall situation for Rachel has not significantly changed it is at least a side note which they could enjoy.
If you are new to the series, I would not recommend this book as the jumping in point. Go back to the first book and start there. By the time you get here you will have decided for yourself. I have the next book in the series in my read pile and I do plan to read it so take that into consideration when you read this.